Players who played for Everton and Sheffield United

21 players have played for both Everton and Sheffield United, according to Wikidata. The best known include Phil Jagielka, Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Gary Speed. 7 of them moved straight from one club to the other, including Phil Jagielka. The earliest arrival at one of the two clubs was in 1976 (Bruce Rioch), the most recent in 2019 (Iliman Ndiaye).

The full list (21 players)

PlayerPositionNationalityEvertonSheffield United
Phil JagielkaDefenderEngland2007–20192000–2021
Dominic Calvert-LewinForwardEngland2016–20252014–2016
Gary SpeedMidfielderWales1996–19982008–2010
Jack RodwellMidfielderEngland2007–20122020–2021
Conor CoadyDefenderEnglandsince 20222013–2014
Iliman NdiayeForwardSenegal2024–20262019–2023
Richard WrightGoalkeeperUnited Kingdom2002–20072010–2011
James BeattieForwardEngland2005–20072007–2012
David CarneyMidfielderAustralia2002–20032007–2009
Marcus BentForwardUnited Kingdom2004–20061999–2011
Stuart McCallMidfielderScotland1988–19912002–2005
Bruce RiochMidfielderScotland1976–19771979
Li TieForwardPeople's Republic of China2002–20062006–2008
Jose BaxterForwardUnited Kingdom2008–20182013–2016
Iain TurnerGoalkeeperScotland2003–20112014–2015
Gary AblettDefenderEngland1992–19961996
Terry PhelanDefenderIreland1997–20002001
Adrian HeathMidfielderUnited Kingdom1982–19881995–1996
Earl BarrettDefenderUnited Kingdom1995–19981998
David UnsworthDefenderUnited Kingdom1992–20042005–2007
Gary NaysmithDefenderScotland2000–20072007–2010

Players ranked from best known to least known (number of language editions of their Wikipedia page). Data from Wikidata: spotted a mistake? Let us know.

Other club pairs

With Everton

With Sheffield United